The Canmaker Summit 2019 – London
The future of packaging is with metal. But for canmakers to be successful they must embrace disruptive change. Rick Pendrous reports
The global canmaking sector stands at a pivotal juncture in its long and distinguished history. Huge commercial opportunities are on offer to those bold enough to grasp the change that is necessary to ensure a bright metallic future. However, those opportunities come with some big challenges that must be surmounted if success is to be assured.
While the sustainability credentials of metal packaging compared with plastics are well recognised by those working in the industry, much more needs to be done to spread the word among food and drink brand owners and consumers, many of whom remain woefully unaware of the metal can’s potential to be central to the creation of a circular economy.
That was one of the main messages to emerge from The Canmaker Summit, which was held in London for the first time over two days on 9-10 October.
The hugely successful event, which attracted more than 200 delegates, kicked off on the evening before with an informal reception held at the spectacular St Paul’s Cathedral.
During the following two days, delegates heard from speakers covering everything from new technical developments in chromium-free tinplate production and the challenging aluminium pricing environment for beverage canmakers, to the huge potential on offer to canmakers that take novel approaches to their product designs.
Celebrating success
First up on the opening day was Stephen McAneny, group vice president commercial of Canpack Group, the Poland-based canmaker that has operations around the globe.
Although relatively new to his post, McAneny has long experience in packaging and was able to bring a fresh perspective to the potential new prospects open to the canmaking sector today. These opportunities need to be grasped with both hands if the industry is to take maximum advantage of them, he suggested.
It is crucial to identify and celebrate what makes a successful company, remarked McAneny. It hinges on good leadership, motivation and culture within organisations, as well as good brand management, he said. And it often requires being a “disrupter” in the market, challenging perceived wisdoms – an idea further developed by a subsequent speaker, Robert Monaghan, a designer with innovation and design company Air.
However, what differentiates really successful firms, said McAneny, is the way they engage with their customers and consumers. “It’s about having imagination,” he said, especially given the dynamic nature of the packaging market currently and the speed of change being experienced, he added.
“The time is now: there is no question that the aluminium can is an iconic product – this is the moment,” said McAneny. “For us as a company, it’s about thinking big. We have very big dreams; we have big aspirations.” However, to be successful, it is necessary to spread the word about the capabilities of the can – both to brand owners and consumers, he added.
He also emphasised the need to recognise that young people today expect far more from the brands with which they engage. So, he added, it is necessary to pose the question: “What is it that makes us stand out?”
However, the industry also faces some big challenges, said McAneny. These include the spread of deposit return schemes (DRSs) on single-use beverage containers, which are being taken up by more countries globally. This has the potential to damage the canned drink sector if it is introduced in a similar way to how Germany implemented its DRS in 2003. “There is a huge problem bubbling here if we get it wrong,” he warned.
Call to arms
Robert Fell, chief executive of the UK’s Metal Packaging Manufacturers Association (MPMA), also issued a call to arms for the industry to do more to promote the sustainability of aluminium and steel packaging and to spread the word about its efforts to further reduce the environmental impact, highlighting the dramatic weight reductions in cans already achieved.
But the energy-saving merits of using recycled aluminium and steel also needed to be promulgated, he added. He pointed to energy savings of consuming canned rather than chilled or frozen food. Canned food only requires heating from ambient temperatures in the home, whereas chilled and frozen food consumes more energy to be heated up. If that weren’t enough, switching to canned food could help reduce the huge 1.3 billion tonne a year global problem of food waste, he added.
Clearly brand owners, canners and canmakers need to do far more to convince consumers that canned food is not old fashioned but is in fact a packaging fit for the future. Like other presenters, Fell stressed the untapped potential of the metal can: “We’ve only just scratched the surface of what we can do with cans.”
Thinking outside the box
Robert Monaghan from brand design and innovation consultancy Air explained how much more could be done with can design to engage with consumers. New ideas could be adopted from designs used in areas where metal isn’t traditionally used as a packaging material, Monaghan suggested.
He advised those taking this approach to follow four guiding principles: offer designs that others don’t; keep the design simple; remember that coming up with ideas is easy, putting them into practice isn’t; and, lastly, collaboration is key. He showed various examples where metal packaging had been instrumental in creating elegant, new types of packaging. Tantalisingly, he also showed examples where it was possible but had yet to happen.
With global consumer goods giant Unilever planning to halve the 700,000 tonnes of plastic packaging it uses each year over the next five years to reduce its carbon footprint, metal packaging had a lot to go for, Monaghan urged. “This industry is in a position of high potential,” he remarked. “The trouble is, the can lives at the bottom of the cupboard, while the centre of activity is in the fridge.”
It’s all about drawing on the inherent versatility of metal packaging and using smart design and printing approaches to provide promotional opportunities and consumer individualisation, and solving problems for people, said Monaghan. As an example, he used the introduction of metal aerosols to replace plastic packaging in the US to deliver Unibond bathroom sealant. “We need to have more innovation to break the price lock we are in,” he added.
Hermann Kirner, business manager for Metallbildner of Germany, who brought to life the Beck’s flute, an ambitious design which won The Canmaker Summit delegates’ favourite Can of the Year in 2018, explained the challenges of developing it. Like Monaghan, he stressed the importance of keeping things simple when presented with complex design challenges.
Kirner explained that his non-canmaking background meant that he came to it with no preconceptions. He described how he arrived at the solution of pressing a standard can into the pre-formed flute, and developed a special rig which could be used to assemble cans into a variety of shapes for marketing campaigns.
Chromium-free alternative
In a joint presentation from Thyssenkrupp Rasselstein in Germany, Dr Martin Schlupp, head of surface technology and chemistry, and Carmen Tschage, head of communications and market development, described the science behind the packaging steelmaker’s new chromium-free passivation alternative (CFPA) technology for tinplate, which is now available to the canmaking industry.
Rasselstein is one of the first of the European steelmakers out of the block in making a CFPA available to the industry under a development programme co-ordinated by the Association of European Producers of Steel for Packaging (APEAL). The CFPA technology has been developed to comply with new rules prohibiting hexavalent chromium, widely used for tinplate passivation.
Under the Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals (REACH) legislation, hexavalent chromium (chromium6+) chemicals are to be banned.
However, in February 2019, following representations from APEAL, the REACH committee recommended to the European Commission that steel strip producers should be given a derogation for another four years to allow them sufficient time to make the necessary changes to their production lines and provide safer alternatives to the use of hexavalent chromium for passivation of tinplate.
Schlupp explained that Rasselstein’s CFPA comprises a mixture of titanium and zirconium oxides embedded in a polymer matrix as an alternative to using chromium trioxide (chromium6+) under tinplate passivation process standards 300/311.
During a question and answer session, Schlupp explained that while the steelmaker’s CFPA product is now available to the market, canmakers intending to use it should assess its compatibility with their varnishes and fillings. He explained that, since more than 1,000 varnish formulations are currently used, Rasselstein has not been able to assess the performance of its CFPA against all of them.
Apprentices make a difference
In the last presentation of the first day, Andrew Truelove, general manager for CarnaudMetalbox Engineering (CMbE) in the UK, raised the issue of the skills gap in manufacturing industries and described his company’s approach to training and retaining skilled staff, with particular reference to its apprenticeship programme – something the canmaking equipment supplier had been involved with for the past 85 years.
Truelove introduced three of CMbE’s young engineering apprentices to the stage who very eloquently and confidently gave first-hand accounts of their experiences under the company’s apprenticeship programme and their involvement representing the UK at the WorldSkills competition at Kazan in Russia in August 2019.
Promoting the recyclability message
Jason Ramskill, vice president of operations at Ball Beverage Packaging Europe in the UK, opened the second day of the Summit. He discussed the trends and opportunities in
metal beverage packaging as the world increasingly rejects a throwaway environment in favour of more circular economies in which the aim is to eliminate waste. Ramskill echoed the comments of other presenters in stressing the imperative of promoting the recyclability message of cans.
While aluminium beverage cans have an incredibly strong green message to impart, with a current global aluminium can recycling rate of 69 per cent (74.5 per cent in Europe) and growing, Ramskill pointed out that recycling rates should reflect real recycling and the reality is that the EU’s official recycling rate is equivalent to the collection rate.
As the EU works to standardise the calculation of recycling rates at the point of recycling, the figures for all materials – aluminium cans, glass and PET bottles, and drinks cartons – are destined to fall, he announced. However, this will be to the advantage of cans, since the difference between metal and other materials is likely to increase substantially as a result, he told delegates.
Ramskill described how brands are increasingly adopting cans for their packaging: from water and wine to beer and iced coffee. They are taking advantage of the modern innovative design capabilities of cans, as well as the use of augmented reality and speciality printing techniques, he added.
These new product launches are being targeted at consumer health and wellbeing and individualisation, and Ball has been very successful in collaborating on the introduction of a number of new products in these areas, he explained: “We have a tail wind and we feel it.”
But it is important to maintain a philosophy of continuous improvement, Ramskill added. With this in mind, Ball is taking the cans it produces and the plants producing them to the next level of sustainability. The canmaker has set targets for the reduction of waste and pollutants generated together with targets for cutting utility consumption in its factories.
Building on the comments made by McAneny on the first day, he agreed that success comes from investing in your people, as much as in the company’s physical assets.
“At Ball, we are investing for growth and we break this down into three areas: there is the product, the process and the people,” he said. He also reported that in May 2019 Ball founded the European Women’s Network to encourage greater diversity in its workplace. Diversity is seen as critical to the company’s future commercial success.
A craft brewer’s perspective
Ball customer Steve Morris, head of operations at Fourpure Brewing Co in the UK, followed Ramskill and reinforced his message about growing consumer demand for greater sustainability by explaining how the craft brewer was addressing this issue. In 2015, Fourpure moved from supplying its beer in bottles to cans to take advantage of the benefits of aluminium in quality and environmental impact.
The UK craft beer market offers considerable potential for growth,
said Morris. Currently, it represents just 5 per cent of the total beer sector, compared with around 23 per cent in the US, he reported. “All the new [craft brewery] entrants are in cans.”
However, as Fourpure has progressively enhanced the designs it uses on its canned beer, it has been presented with the conundrum of how to meet demand for short run production in this market where constant innovation is expected.
Recognising that customers also want greater sustainability as well as innovation in the premium beer purchases they make, Fourpure is concerned that applying paper labels and shrink wrap to cans might not send out the correct green message. Consequently, Morris is considering the use of more sustainable solutions, such as direct-to-can digital printing.
Market analysis
In the penultimate presentation of the Summit, Debbie Jones, a director with Deutsche Bank in the UK, presented a fascinating analysis of the business performance of key publicly quoted canmaking companies Ardagh, Ball, Crown and Silgan.
While she highlighted the huge new opportunities on offer to canmakers – particularly in the beverage can sector – with the global focus on the sustainability of packaging materials and a backlash against single-use plastics, she warned delegates about the dangers of disruption to the market caused by new entrants to the market.
Jones also highlighted the North American decline in demand for food cans. For example, total food can shipments in the US were down
approximately 11 per cent between 2008 and 2018, with shipments of three-piece tinplate cans down a whopping 37 per cent to 7.5 billion,
she said. However, this was offset by a 7.5 per cent rise in two-piece food can shipments to 18.9bn, she reported.
While the beverage can sector might be booming, the volatility of aluminium coil prices was creating a challenging environment for canmakers, said Kamil Wlazly, senior metals analyst for aluminium markets with consultancy group Wood Mackenzie UK in the final presentation of the Summit.
Key areas of concern for aluminium canmakers were likely to be fears of a global economic slowdown in 2020, the impact of changes in aluminium coil production in China, US tariffs and growth in demand for aluminium automotive sheet in Japan, Europe and the US, which could eat away at canstock capacity, suggested Wlazly.
Nevertheless, despite the macroeconomic and political challenges facing the canmaking sector, the general feeling of delegates at the 2019 Canmaker Summit was notably upbeat.
“It was good to see the metal packaging industry in the most
buoyant mood I can remember during my 20 years,” remarked one delegate.
The general feeling of optimism at the Summit was best summed up by Canpack’s McAneny, who emphasised that with the focus of global attention on sustainability and the future survival of our planet, the canmaking industry had a crucial role to play.
“This is an important time in this industry,” McAneny concluded.


